Quote:
Originally Posted by STL PHL
I agree to a point however;\
Private school tuition for Pre-K is ~$13k (plus afterschool, plus summer if you area dual areer family). Catholic school is less. Private high school ~$24k at some places.
Multiple by 2 means a bunch of money.
The burbs have yards. 5 year old can go play in the back; can't really have a 5 year old walk by themselves to a park 4 blocks away. TOugh to always go with the 5 year old as the younger one nap durring the day at the house
Assuming your job is not in the city..wage tax
And the public schools are not very good; even the good ones, well..aren't (Going by the numbers)
All that being said, I am trying to stay; but wonder if it is best for me or the kids. It is a hard decisions and I no longer think poorly of those who leave or stay.
|
I think we'll see an interesting cultural shift when gas continues upwards. There's a year and a half wait list on Priuses in Rochester, NY right now (my mom sells 'em...so it's my only source!). I'm going to venture that people not being able to afford long commutes and/or want to afford private schools for their children will be the catalyst to improving city schools. More parents that care and fight for change will be the only thing to undo the erosion of city schools that suburbanization/white flight originally caused.
I'm also going to guess that public transportation around here will also improve. It's an interesting time to live in a major metropolitan city.
But also, you cannot really over-idealize being raised in the burbs. There's nowhere in America a responsible parent should send a child a few blocks away alone these days, let alone unsupervised in a yard. Plenty of kids go missing in rural and suburban areas everyday and it's a very sad thing. I think raising a child in the city makes you less likely to lose sight of your children, more likely to supervise the friends they have, places they go. It's also much more likely your child will be in a diverse school and get a much more enriching social and cultural education.
Being a product of a great suburban school, I can tell you it's not a panacea. I don't judge people or parents that leave at all (it's easy to be someone who criticizes others when I have no children of my own) but sometimes think people view the suburbs as someplace that's totally perfect...that their kids won't stumble into daily drug use, that their friends will all be college bound and that big yards=higher SAT scores...doesn't work that way, unfortunately and there are definitely positives to urban living for children.